‘Star Trek: The Next Generation’ Retro Recap – ‘Unnatural Selection’

Written by John Edward Betancourt

If there is one thing that we can all agree upon, it would have to be that science has been a blessing upon the whole of mankind. For it has allowed for us to beat back horrible illnesses that once ravaged our species, and it’s made the world a tighter knit place by way of technology. Something that has allowed for people in different parts of the planet to communicate with each other on a moment’s notice. And of course, it’s taken us to the heavens above, inspiring so many to reach for the impossible since it can be achieved. But what matters most about all of these feats, is that they came about by way of honest work. For there were no shortcuts taken when the scientific community worked to create these wonders, there was just dedication and care to get it done the right way so that mankind could reap the benefits. 

In fact, the integrity that science exhibits as a whole is what makes it so incredibly special. Because few ever deviate from its standards and that’s a wonderful thing. Because in the wrong hands or arrogant ones for that matter, bad things could come about, a truth that is often explored heavily in fiction. For that is a safe place to explore the dangers that could come forth from cutting corners in regard to the scientific method, and it just so happens that this particular exploration took place in the next episode of Star Trek: The Next Generation. For ‘Unnatural Selection’ saw an experiment involving the human genome backfire horribly thanks to arrogance and the drive for fast results from a group of scientists, something that forced the crew of the Enterprise to think on their feet to find a cure for what carelessness bought about, and that made for one compelling episode.

One that oddly enough, finally allowed for Doctor Katherine Pulaski to really contribute to the story. Because up until now, she’s been nothing more than either background scenery or a voice in the room designed to push the plot along. But here, she finally got to really show us how dedicated she is as a physician since a medical experiment gone awry is right in her wheelhouse, and once the Enterprise was able to trace the genesis of a pathogen that aged humans rapidly to a nearby research facility, the Doctor was finally able to shine. Because she was determined to no end to figure out the finer details of this virus, so that a cure or a treatment could be found, and if that meant putting herself in harm’s way, then so be it. Which spoke volumes to how dedicated she is to saving lives and it was just wonderful to finally see her in action and of course to see the crew back her up when things went horribly wrong. 

Because she did contract the virus after all, and with no cure in sight it seemed as though there was no hope for the good doctor. But that certainly didn’t stop Captain Picard from demanding the best from his crew and putting every option on the table. Including the supremely unique idea of using the transporter to restore the doctor’s DNA to her previous state. Which was a risky gamble for certain since its failure would mean the end of Doctor Pulaski, but it was one that Picard was willing to take, especially if it saved her life and countless others, and wouldn’t you know it? The plan actually worked, and Doctor Pulaski was restored to her former and younger self, allowing for an immediate cure to be found and for research on how to fix this mess to continue.

If anything, this was simply a by the numbers, engrossing tale and it is great. For it features a mystery for the crew for the solve, some light commentary on genetic engineering and of course everyone working together to solve the problem. Which is a formula that always works on this series. But more importantly, what makes this story truly stand out, is the sheer fact that it finally allows for Doctor Pulaski to take the center stage. And it was just a delight to see her and Captain Picard finally shed their animosity and work together in proper fashion and see her be an actual part of this crew. Which just goes to show, that had she received proper development and care, she would have been a valued addition to this series. But what is done is done, and while the good doctor may not have received the same care she gave to others, at least we have this gem of a story to showcase her potential. Until next time.   

---