A Review of Season 2 of ‘Based on a True Story’

Written by John Edward Betancourt

BASED ON A TRUE STORY -- "Liquid Gold" Episode 201 -- Pictured: (l-r) Kaley Cuoco as Ava, Chris Messina as Nathan -- (Photo by: Casey Durkin/PEACOCK)

It is definitely safe to say, that most fictional stories about people that take on a serial killer, in any capacity, end in a supremely similar manner. Wherein the good citizen or citizens or detective chasing this killer… confront the monster at last. Which gives rise to an epic showdown where good usually conquers evil, and thus the killer goes to jail for the rest of their days or takes their last breath, depending on how the writer decides to end the story, and well… that’s that. There are some brief moments of reflection before the hero or heroes, just pick up the pieces and move toward an unknown future as the story fades to black or the page reads THE END.
​
Which makes for amazing entertainment for certain, and some satisfying endings… but they are incomplete finales at best. After all, anyone who comes toe to toe with a killer, would be transformed from a psychological standpoint. Because that’s a harrowing brush with death, and life changing to say the least, and it would be worthwhile to explore something that powerful and moving. Not to mention, what is life, like for a killer when the killing stops? Because that too would be an adjustment worthy of a good story and well, at long last… it would seem that one particular series is eager to ponder upon such matters.

Which are feats that season two of Based on a True Story accomplish, by way of a unique new plot. Wherein we reunite with Ava and Nathan, after some resolution regarding their little problem in knowing an outright serial killer. Which allows for us to quickly see, who we would become after facing such a stressful situation and at the same time, who a killer would become when murder is no longer part of the order of the day since Matt is faced with that prospect as well in this season, and that brings about… an incredible new season of storytelling. One filled with deep reflection for the characters as they begin to ponder upon a new chapter where survival and fear is no longer the order of the day and that alone is worth the price of admission for season two.

Since it finally takes us into that part of the story we never see and does so in a compelling and oddly realistic manner. But of course, while those elements would be enough to carry this season from beginning to end, it features so much more for us to chew upon. In fact, the show’s trademark commentary and depth regarding the human condition in the modern world, is present here, and it dives into new territory as well. The kind that is supremely reflective in nature and deeply fascinating, and much of that relates to the many journeys present here, and yet there are still more wonders to discuss. Since season two also features some bold surprises, and that trademark black comedy that made season one so enjoyable here, is also present.

Not to mention, the cast elevates their acting game in season two, which is no small feat. Since they were so good in season one. But now, they’re comfortable with their characters, and that allows for them to take their performances new places, and all of this brings forth, a magnificent season of storytelling. One that is bold, thoughtful and downright entertaining. Courtesy of great humor, grand ideas and moments that you’ve likely noticed we’ve steered clear of breaking down in detail. Because spoilers here would be cruel, and you need to experience the majesty of this new season firsthand and the good news is, you don’t have to wait much longer. For season two of Based on a True Story drops on Peacock tomorrow, and we cannot wait for you to see it, nor can we wait to share our interviews with Executive Producer Michael Costigan and Actor Liana Liberato (Tory), as our celebration of the release of season two of this magnificent show continues along. Until next time.

---